Criteria and Grading Matrix for News Essays

Criteria and Grading Matrix for News Essays

What is News?

For purposes of these essays, news is
considered anything dealing with serious world or domestic policy issues. For example, this year’s elections, the
current problems with ISIS, the fight over gun control legislation, etc.
For purposes of this class, the following
is NOTconsidered news:
.png” alt=”Text box: 1. human interest stories about animal rescues from trees;
2. any stories about traffic jams on i-25;
3. any stories about peyton manning or prince george.

“>

These essays are to be concerned with serious news, not infotainment as we like to call it. If
you have any doubt about your topic, ask before writing it.

Since our focus is on international relations and foreign policy,
this should also be the subject of your news essays.
What are News Sources?

The following are good domestic news
sources, and you will also find coverage of international events in some of
them. These include news magazines, such as Time, the Economist, U.S. News and
World Report, National Journal, Foreign Affairs, etc. Newspapers such as the
Denver Post, the Washington Post, the Christian Science Monitor, the Wall
Street Journal, the Hill, etc. are also quite good. CQ Researcher, found in the
library data base, is outstanding in its treatment of current issues.
Please stay away from all television news,
do not use the opinion page for your sources, avoid blogs, and do not quote
political pundits such as Glenn Beck or Rachel Maddow. Do not use Wikipedia! You may also cite from
policy papers written by think tanks such as the Heritage Foundation, the
American Enterprise Institute, the Center for American Progress, the Council on
Foreign Relations, or the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities. National
Public Radio and PBS are great sources for news analysis. Good foreign news sources
include BBC and Al Jazeera English. In addition, this link .onlinenewspapers.com/”>http://www.onlinenewspapers.com/will
take you to a website that contains links to news sources around the world.
The above list is not meant to be
all-inclusive. It merely provides a few examples of what constitutes news
sources.
You will need to use at least 3 different sourcesabout the same topic.
The library has a good database called EBSCO which contains newspapers and
newsmagazines. You can search the database by topic and it will bring up many
more sources than you can possibly use. You may also use Google scholar.
Structure/Format
1.
Introduction – why did you choose this
particular issue, and how it is relevant to politics and the course material.
2.
Summarize the key points in the story.
3.
Discussthe various perspectives you
found in the three different sources. Did they stress different aspects of the
issue? Did any of them seem particularly biased? Why, or why not?
4.
Summarize and provide an overview of your own thoughts on the issue. Do you agree or disagree with the source material, do
you hold a different viewpoint based on other reasons?
5.
Conclusion– sum up what you have
written, and end with any last thoughts or comments you wish to make.
Grading Matrix

.png”>Grade

90-100/A

80-89/B

70-79/C

60-69/D

.png”>Criteria

Length

Meets the
length requirements – 3 -3 1/2pages long.

Falls short
of the length requirement – 2 ½ pages rather than the 3-3 1/2-page minimum.

Falls short
of length requirement – 2 pages or less

Only 1 or 1 ½
pages.

Content

Contains an analysis of a substantive news issue.

Contains an analysis of a substantive news issue.

Topic is either irrelevant or not substantive news.

Topic is not news-related.

Structure

Contains a
clear introduction, a summary of the issue to be discussed, and an analysis.
The analysis should include an examination of how this issue is relevant,
what are the different arguments you found regarding the issue, and whether
you agree or disagree. The paper concludes with a substantive summary of the
thoughts and ideas contained in the paper.

Contains a
clear introduction, a summary of the issue to be discussed, and an analysis.
The analysis should include an examination of how this issue is relevant,
what are the different arguments you found regarding the issue, and whether
you agree or disagree. The paper concludes with a substantive summary of the
thoughts and ideas contained in the paper.

Does not
contain one or more of the following:
A clear
introduction, a substantive analysis, any of your own thoughts, or a
substantive summary.

Structure is
poor – lacks a clear introduction, analysis and summary.

Quality
of Writing

Spelling and grammar are correct. Sentence structure is
good. Paper is well-organized.

Spelling and/or grammar is incorrect in just a few
places. Sentence structure is not consistently good throughout the paper.
Organization is good, but less than solid.

Spelling and grammar are incorrect in many places.
Sentence structure is poor throughout the paper. Organization needs work.

Spelling and grammar are unacceptable. Sentence structure
is consistently poor throughout the paper. Lacks any coherent organization.

Source
Material

Contains a
bibliography of source material. Uses at least 3 different legitimate news sources.

Contains a
bibliography of source material. Uses at least 2 different legitimate news
sources.

Order your essay today and save 30% with the discount code: KIWI20